Monday, October 20, 2008

Veracity of Tabari's Islamic History - 50

aijaz alamdar wrote:

Dear Aamir Sahab

Its not necessary that if Naqavi Sahib agree with one Bukhari hadith then he should accept all the ahadith by Bukhari--The way you put this objection reflect your narrow mind & low level of intellect--The word Sahi is not used by shia. Regarding Mauwiah being maloon & should be cursed by Allah & His Angels is not by virtue of one hadith against this maloon ibn-e-maloon- -its history which is consistent with his evil character.


Dear Alamdar Sahab,

Then why did Hazrat Hassan and Hussein [May Allah be pleased with them] accepted Hazrat Muawiyah [May Allah be pleased with him]'s Khilafa and they were both used to receive very heavy annual amount from Hazrat Muawiyah [May Allah be pleased with him].

You are very fond of History, I will be quoting History. Bukhari's Hadith was sufficient for me that Hazrat Hassan [May Allah be pleased with him] made peace with Hazrat Muawiya [May Allah be pleased with him] and Hussain [May Allah be pleased with him] also accepted that Khilafa.

Shia and Sunni Sources on Hasnain's acceptance of Muawiyah's Khilafa:

[Akhbar Al Tawal Al Denwary page 234, Tabari Page 62 Volume 6, Al Imama Wal Siyasa page 173, Maqtal Abi Mikhnaf page 4 published in Najaf]

Hazrat Muawiya [May Allah be pleased with him]'s Excellent Treatment with Hasan and Hussain [May Allah be pleased with both of them]:

Hussain used to go with Hasan to meet Muawiyah in Damascus and at one stance Muawiyah gifted 2 Million Dirham to both and at anothe ocassion he gifted Hazrat Hasan 4 Million Dirham [Al Bidaya Wal Nihaya by Ibn Kathir Page 150 and Page 127 Volume 8] This narration is confirmed by Ibn Abi Al Hadid (Mutazilli Shia) in his translation of Nehjul Balagha page 823 Volume 2] and this further confirmed by Extremist Shias like Abu Mikhnaf in his book Maqtal Abi Mikhnaf page 7].

Should I quote as to how bravely Hazrat Hussain [May Allah be pleased with him] fought under the command of Yazid Bin Muawiyah [May Allah have mercy on his soul] in Constantinople. I will quote Shia sources of History you praise.

Note: Maqtal Abi Mikhnaf is a book by Abu Mikhnaf specially written on Karbala Tragedy and from Tabari to present day Speakers of Shia Majlis, this book is quoted for narrating the Tragedy of Karbala.

No comments: