Veracity of Tabari's Islamic History - 18

syed-mohsin naquvi wrote:

Yes, Khumayni did. You probably have not seen Khumaynie's FATAAWA on the status of the present Qur'an.

Syed-Mohsin Naquvi
======================

Dear Syed Sahab,

You say every Shia discredited Tabrasi but Khomeini didn't and if he did than what's this?

"O' Allah, sal ala Muhamed wa ala aal Muhamed and curse the two idols of Quraysh (Abu Bakr and Omar), its (Quraysh's) two sorcerers, its two tyrants, its two liars, and their two daughters (Aysha and Hafsah) who (Abu Bakr and Omar) disagreed with your order, denied your revelation, rejected your goodness, disobeyed your messenger, altered your religion, tampered (harafa) with your Book (Al-Quran), loved your enemy, rejected your lovers, suspended your verdicts, invalidated your orders, did not believe in your proves, antagonized your lovers, patronized your foes, ruined your country, and corrupted your slaves, O' Allah curse them both, their followers, their lovers, their people, their adherents, their partisans, their disciples ............."

That was the Supplication of the Two idols of Quraysh, who the shia bestowed a great importance on it and the shia scholars consider it as a valid supplication. The shia scholars who mentioned that supplication in their books are many, they are not limited to the following, but just as an example: Al-Kaf'ami, Al-Kashani, Al-Nouri Al-Tubrisi, Asadallah Al-Haeiri, Murtada Hussain, Mandhoor Hussain, Al-Karkey, Al-damad Al-Hussaini, Al-Majlisi, Al-Tasaturi, Abu Al-Hassan Al-Amily, Abdullah Shubbar, Al-Haeiri, Mirza Habeeballah and many many more. They are all Ayatuallah, who has the highest rank in shia clergy.

Also Khomeini approved it. In a book called Tuhfat Al-Owam Maqbool, the following scholars agreed on the authenticity of the supplication:

Ayatulallah Sayyed Ali Al-Naqi Al-Naqari

Ayatulallah Sayyed Abu Al-Qasim Al-Kho'ei

Ayatulallah Sayyed Mahmoud Al-Shamroudi

Ayatulallah Sayyed Muhamed Kazim Shari'atmdar

Ayatulallah Sayyed Muhsin Hakeem Al-Tabtiba'ei

Ayatulallah Sayyed Rouhallah Khomenie

Nuri Tibiris, one of the most renowned Shi'ite scholars and mujtahids, wrote a book against the present Quran. The book is entitled: 'Faslul Khitab Fi Tahreefi-Kitabi Rabbil Arbaab' (The Final Verdict on the Distortion of the Book of the Lord of Lords). Khomeini mentions this scholar with great respect in his own book 'Al Hukumatul Islamiyah" (The Islamic State). In fact, Khomeini has actually used Nuri Tibiris's work entitled "Mustadrakul Wasail" to complete his theory of Wilayatul Faqih.

[Wilayatul Faqih is the Islamic jurist's right to overrule a ruling that
contradicts Islamic law.]