Showing posts with label River Indus. Show all posts
Showing posts with label River Indus. Show all posts

Thursday, October 13, 2011

Flood in Sindh: Destruction of Mirpurkhas & Tharparkar. (Courtesy: Dawn/Express)

I used to live in Mirpurkhas, Sindh, between 1970 to 1975 and believe me it was not Paris nor it was Venice and neither it was Singapore but it was a developing city, peaceful and harmonious and one of the salient feature of that District was "Fruit Gardens and Farms" specifically "Mango Farms"  and what we have in 2011! Lets have a look - KARACHI: Rains damaged about a two-third of the cotton areas in Mirpurkhas, the second largest cotton-growing district in the Sindh. The cotton crop is 70 percent at the dented stage. With only 30 percent of the current cotton crop rated fair or better as of this Friday, crop conditions were well behind where they were at this time last year. Out of six tehsils (sub-districts) of Mirpurkhas, considered rich among cotton belt, Jhudo, Kot Ghulam Muhammad, Digri and Sindhri were affected from recent rains. While Sanghar is the leading district countrywide, Mirpurkhas had been forecasted the second largest cotton producer district in Sindh this year. This year Mirpurkhas was estimated to increase production from 405,000 bales a year ago, official sources said. “The rains were severe, so irrigated acreage in most areas had emergence issues and now irrigated crops are suffering,” source said. Mirpurkhas planted 40,400 hectare of soft commodity this season, much of which has already been harmed by heavy showers. “We have been selling a maund of cottonseed at around Rs 2,500 for the last two month, while the prices elsewhere are higher,” a farmer said. Reference: Rain devastates third of Mirpurkhas cotton crop zulfiqar kunbhar Saturday, September 03, 2011 http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=2011%5C09%5C03%5Cstory_3-9-2011_pg5_2 

News Night with Talat - 1 (12th October 2011)



URL: http://youtu.be/H9LPUZWCb3c


The hospital compound is submerged in five feet of water, ambulances have stopped working and the only mode of transport inside is donkey carts. PHOTO: ZEESHAN KHAN/EXPRESS - MIRPURKHAS: Civil Hospital, Mirpurkhas, and the doctors’ residential quarters that surround it, are a bizarre archipelago in a 13-acre sea of rainwater. Gulab, a resident of the Digri Tehsil waded through torrents of floodwater to get to the hospital located in the centre of Mirpurkhas City bearing his six-year-old daughter suffering from pneumonia. Upon reaching the gate, he hired a donkey cart waiting there in order to cross a moat of rain, river and sewerage water only to be told that the hospital is unable to treat chest congestion and he would have to take her to Hyderabad, Lal Batti, instead. From the main gate to the hospital, the water stands at about five feet, while the floor of the hospital is hidden under a layer of muck. The ambulances gave way as water soaked into their engines. A makeshift ramp has been constructed for stretchers and gurneys and a pair of donkey carts have been hired by the hospital to transport their staff inside. The patients, on the other hand, have to pay Rs10 per head for each trip to and from the gate and the hospital. Critical patients – particularly those with heart problems – do not survive the bumpy trip. Though it is the district’s civil hospital, people from the Tharparkar, Sanghar, Umarkot, Mirpurkhas and Tando Allahyar districts all travel here and about 3,000 patients are treated daily. Gulab was turned away from the last functioning ward of the hospital that housed a total of 100 people – doctors included. There are about 1.5 million people living in Mirpurkhas district alone. Like Gulab’s daughter, the majority of patients have to be turned away because the hospital’s supply of medicines and technology has severely been affected. Others simply cannot stomach the filth that fills the wards. Nearby, there is an area known as New Town where there are about six private medical centres. The queues outside these clinics are longer than those outside ration distribution centres as people line up, prepared to pay private bills for medical attention. Strangely enough, the road outside is not flooded – roughly 20 days after the rains stopped, only the hospital compound remains flooded. It is one of the areas, including Mirpurkhas, Digri, Diplo and Sanghar, where water remains. Efforts to drain the civil hospital in Sanghar have been abandoned altogether and an emergency centre in an adjoining shop has been setup to help patients in need of urgent medical care. Meanwhile, the Mirpurkhas hospital management, taluka municipal administration and district management are too busy pushing the responsibility of draining the hospital off on each other to actually make any headway towards getting the water out. Their homes flooded and belongings destroyed, even the paramedics and doctors living in the hospital compound have shifted away. Probably the only upside is that the electricity supply is still up and, during load-shedding, the hospital generators are also functioning. Not to be overlooked either is the dedication of the doctors who wait at the gate for patients, working with what little they have. In the days that have passed since the water flowed down from the saltwater drain to the left of the district, sewerage from the hospital has mixed into the water. The doctors say that the sanitation problem is so bad that they are not even sure what kind of diseases are spreading in the hospital. The most common complaints, after gastroenteritis and malaria, are skin diseases. Swimming through the stew of sewerage, rainwater and mud are fish weighing up to 200 grammes. According to social worker Kanji Dheel, the situation is worsened by certain influential landlords who are draining their agricultural lands and sending the water towards Mirpurkhas City. with additional writing by husna anwar Published in The Express Tribune, September 28th, 2011. REFERENCE: In Mirpurkhas, Rs10 is the fare for a donkey cart ride between life and death By Afaq Khan Published: September 28, 2011 http://tribune.com.pk/story/262069/in-mirpurkhas-rs10-is-the-fare-for-a-donkey-cart-ride-between-life-and-death/ 

News Night with Talat - 2 (12th October 2011)



URL: http://youtu.be/N2hW3-88ZA8


The hospital compound is submerged in five feet of water, ambulances have stopped working and the only mode of transport inside is donkey carts. PHOTO: ZEESHAN KHAN/EXPRESS - MIRPURKHAS, Sept 25: Several wards of the Civil Hospital in Mirpurkhas have been closed and 80 per cent doctors and other staff members have stopped coming to work with the hospital premises being under four feet water for weeks. Indoor patients had to leave the hospital without treatment. Hundreds of patients coming to the hospital from Sanghar, Umerkot, Tharparkar and Tando Allahyar have no place to turn to. The municipal and other authorities have failed to drain out water and the wards of gynaecology, paediatrics, surgery, ENT, cardiac and Kidney have been closed. People suffering from gastroenteritis, malaria, skin disease and dehydration are unable to get any treatment. Hospital waste and heaps of filth are lying at different places posing serious health hazards and providing breeding ground for mosquitoes and flies. Sondha, Rewa, Nandlal and other patients told this reporter that they had been displaced from their homes and now they suffered from different diseases and had to go to private clinics. Chairman of the Citizen Action Committee Rais Ahmed Khan and Kamran Kaimkhani regretted that the hospital which provided treatment to thousands of people was lying closed because of inefficiency of the district administration, departments concerned, TMA Mirpurkhas and the hospital administration. They urged the authorities to take immediate steps to drain out water from the hospital premises. A FLOODED CITY: Rainwater mixed with sewage and saline water of Dhoro Puran stagnating in the town for a couple of weeks has created a serious problem for the people. Sweepers of the taluka municipal administration were seen breaking some sewage drains to drain out water. Some heavy pumping machines are being used at the railway station roundabout and other places. About two to three feet of water has entered residential areas and inundated the DCO office, food godowns and offices of the excise and taxation department, district food controller and EDO health. Floodwater also hit the offices of the district council, director information, EDO agriculture, anti-corruption establishment and police complex, civil hospital, DIG house, circuit house, police lines, town police station, Sindh horticulture research institute, district and sessions court, Shah Abdul Latif science college and the government high school. ADJOINING AREAS: Jhuddo taluka has been cut off from Mirpurkhas with the main road under six feet of water. Two to three feet of water is flowing through the town and villages on its outskirts. The roads linking Jhuddo town with nearby villages have also been inundated. Distribution of relief goods among displaced people, who are living in the open, was stopped by the administration two weeks ago. On Saturday, some army trucks carrying foodstuff reached the taluka of Jhuddo. Half of the goods were distributed while the rest was snatched by the enraged people. Digri taluka is also under four feet of water. About four to five feet of water is stagnating in the rural areas of the talukas of Mirpurkhas, Hussain Bux Mari and Sindhri. Although some relief goods are being distributed in Mir Ji Landhi, 10 Mile Mori and adjoining villages in the taluka of Kot Ghulam Mohammad, a large number of affected people are not getting any help. TANDO JAN MOHAMMAD: President of the Sindh Chamber for Agriculture, Mirpurkhas chapter, Mir Zafarullah Talpur, told Dawn that the town of Tando Jan Mohammad had been submerged because of a man-made breach in a canal embankment near Digri. He said growers were diverting water towards Khatyan minor, increasing the level of water in Tando Jan Mohammad town. He said that 80 per cent of the people of the town had moved to other places. He alleged that relief goods were being distributed mostly on political basis while a large number of villagers were living without any help. He said four to five feet of water was standing on the outskirts of the town and there was no way to drain it out. REFERENCE: Several wards of Mirpurkhas Civil Hospital remain closed By Qamaruddin | From the Newspaper September 26, 2011 http://www.dawn.com/2011/09/26/several-wards-of-mirpurkhas-civil-hospital-remain-closed.html

News Night with Talat - 3 (12/12/11)



http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5zh5YDTOkgw

News night with talat - 12th october 2011



http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JdagT5oyFlE

MIRPURKHAS: Monsoon floods that sunk Pakistan’s arable belt for a second year running have piled farming losses clocking up to nearly $2 billion on top of a humanitarian catastrophe facing up to eight million people in the south. Crops of grain, cotton, sugarcane, fruit and vegetables have been submerged and experts say the disaster could worsen the country’s already dismal growth and inflation prospects. (Read: Urgent cause:  FAO to raise $18.9m to save livestock)  “It could (also) increase inflation by two to three percent by the end of this calendar year – from 13 to a maximum of 16 percent,” the official said. Exports are likely to be hit as Pakistan struggles to provide enough food to feed its own population in the wake of the floods, said independent economist Rauf Nizamani. “The floods will certainly affect the trade and may cause a loss of at least $3 billion to the Pakistani exchequer,” Nizamani said, leaving export receipts at $25 billion for the fiscal year. The UN’s Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO) estimates that nearly three quarters of southern Sindh province’s crops have been damaged or destroyed by the waters, while two thirds of food stocks have also been hit. Sindh’s agriculture ministry said the financial cost of crop losses so far was estimated at 163 billion Pakistani rupees ($1.87 billion). Cotton faces losses of $998 million, income from chilli crops will be down $427 million and both rice and sugarcane will lose an estimated $135 million, said Aghah Jan Akhtar, the ministry’s secretary. One year after the country experienced its worst-ever floods, affecting 21 million people, farmers were again viewing their fields with despair. In Mirpurkhas, one of the most fertile and badly-flooded districts, the branches of the cotton plants were blackened with water damage, and the usually white buds were colourless and droopy. Rice plants that usually bloom above watery paddy fields were completely submerged, while stalks of sugarcane were miserably short at five feet tall. “This catastrophe struck before families affected by last year’s flooding were able to even start recovering,” said FAO Pakistan representative Kevin Gallagher. “The floods and rain deepen the risk of losing more vital livestock assets and for some, missing another opportunity to plant wheat and other essential crops.” “Besides that, we have lost $180 million through the destruction of tomato, onion, banana and other vegetable crops,” he said. Agriculture makes up 23 percent of Pakistan’s GDP and a senior finance ministry official, who did not want to be named, estimated that the country’s overall growth rate could fall from 4.5 to three percent on current trends. Pakistan’s largest agricultural trading customers are the United States, which takes more than one fifth of cotton, textiles and rice exports, and China, which takes 15 percent. (Sindh floods: UN launches international appeal) Badar Khwaja, a farmer in Tando Bago town in Badin district, forlornly pointed at his flooded paddy fields. He had planned to harvest them just one day after the heavy rains began to fall in August. “The rains have destroyed farmers and peasants alike,” said Khwaja. In nearby Tando Allahyar, known for its quality vegetable production, only 2.5 percent of its usual haul is being trucked to market in Karachi, said local grower Qamar Zaman. “The situation is too critical. We normally feed everyone, but now are ourselves hungry finding no one to feed us,” he said. Kunri town in Mirpurkhas will lose the distinction of being one of the prominent chilli production areas in Asia as 100,000 acres of the red chilli crops have been submerged, said provincial agriculture minister Ali Nawaz Shah. “It is yet another blow to our economy,” he said. In a bitter irony for the farmers, their August harvest due to take place before the floods arrived had been delayed due to water shortage. A lack of irrigation on Sindh’s flatlands had already reduced chilli output from one million tonnes 10 years ago to half that in recent years. “Earlier we suffered because there was no water, but now a deluge has destroyed us,” said grower Ghulam Akbar Dars. Published in The Express Tribune, September 29th, 2011. REFERENCE: Agriculture losses: Flooded breadbasket spells economic misery By AFP Published: September 28, 2011 http://tribune.com.pk/story/262280/floods-2011-farming-losses-reach-2b-say-experts/

News Night with Talat - 1 (11/12/11)



URL: http://youtu.be/VoVJp_p-H8Q


MITHI, Oct 9: Thousands of internally-displaced families living in relief camps or on sand dunes in Thar near Naukot and Kaloi have urged the government and relief agencies to immediately provide tents, food, water and healthcare facilities to the affected people. They also called for a comprehensive survey of losses caused by recent rains and flood. While travelling on the Mithi-Vango, Kaloi-Naukot, Naukot-Mithi roads and some link roads and during recent visits to Kaloi, Naukot and some villages and relief camps, this correspondent saw the entire road network destroyed by rains and portions of the Mithi-Vango road washed away at several places. Scores of villages in the irrigated areas of Kaloi, Bitaro and union councils of Diplo taluka have been cut off from Kaloi, Naukot, Mithi, Badin and other areas. The district administration has failed to drain out water from the Santoro Farm area of Naukot town. Its wholesale market of around 300 shops remains closed. Coaches, buses and trucks cannot use the Naukot road to reach Mithi from Mirpurkhas, Hyderabad, Badin, Karachi or other places. Vehicles are coming to Mithi via Umerkot and Chelhar, which is causing delay in transportation of relief items and other goods. Commuters have to use tractor trolleys or donkey carts to cross the half kilometre of submerged area of Santoro Farm. The authorities have failed to drain out water from the Naukot grid station and power supply to pumping stations for supply of canal water to Mithi remains suspended. The level of water in the Left Bank Outfall Drain, Dhoro Puran and Mehrand Lake near Kaloi continues to be high. Scores of villages around Kaloi, Naukot, Fazal Bhambhro, Nabisar, Talhi, Nafis Nagar, Samaro, Kunri, Jhuddo, Tando Jan Mohammad, Digri, Kot Ghulam Mohammad, Umerkot, Badin and other areas are still submerged in rain and flood water. Almost all the mud houses in these areas have been destroyed, cattle have perished and crops of cotton, sugarcane and vegetables have been damaged. A large number of displaced families is living on the sand dunes of Thar near Kaloi and Naukot or in the poorly-managed relief camps. They are short of food and water and suffering from various diseases. Hundreds of flood-affected people of various villages of Naukot and Kaloi areas are living along the Kaloi-Naukot road with their livestock. Talking to this correspondent in Kaloi, Gomando, Rano, Piro and other haris alleged that landowners were not doing anything to help them in their struggle for survival. They said they had received inadequate ration from an NGO a couple of days ago. “Our Togachi Samo village was submerged at night and we had to abandon it. About 400 families are now living on the road. We got only 40 tents but no relief from the government or any NGO,” said Ayoub, Abdul Majid, Suleman and others. Displaced residents of Ayoub Halo village, now living in relief camps set up in two schools in Kaloi, made similar complaints. They said the camp was dirty and there were no toilets. They are suffering from malaria, diarrhoea, gastroenteritis and skin disease. Ms Hiru, Chibhar Bheel and others living in a relief camp near Naukot fort alleged mismanagement, misappropriation and non-transparency in distribution of relief goods.Meanwhile, Mohammad Khan Loond, finance secretary of the PPP’s Tharparkar chapter, Ali Murad Loond, president of the PPP’s Bolhari union council chapter, and Mohammad Qasim Loond, former nazim of Kaloi UC,said that the district administration and other authorities had ignored the rain-affected areas of Diplo taluka. But district revenue officer Imran Bhatti claimed that the relief operation was going on smoothly and a large number of people living in relief camps or scattered in different places were getting adequate help. He said that the district administration had distributed 15,259 out of the 18,635 tents it had received. Similarly, it had received 106,934 ration bags and so far distributed 73,102 and the process was continuing. REFERENCE: Tharis still awaiting relief on sand dunes By Prem Shivani | From the Newspaper October 10, 2011 http://www.dawn.com/2011/10/10/tharis-still-awaiting-relief-on-sand-dunes.html 

News Night with Talat - 2 (11/12/11)



URL: http://youtu.be/Gj_baJzZCkc


Villagers carry their belongings through floodwater following heavy monsoon rain in Golarchi town in Badin district. PHOTO: AFP HYDERABAD/ISLAMABAD: Heavy rains continued to lash Sindh relentlessly on Tuesday, taking the death toll to 270, as authorities scrambled to cope with rising flood waters, and the UN prepared to launch a flash appeal for international assistance. “At least 270 people have died so far because of falling roofs, drowning in flood waters and outbreak of diseases,” said Sajjad Haider Shah, a disaster management official in Sindh. That figure is expected to rise though, given that 300,000 flood-affected people have so far reported with different illnesses at medical camps across the province, according to statistics released by the department on Tuesday. Tuesday witnessed heavy spells of rains across the province with Karachi, Mithi, Dadu, Tandojam, Sakrand, Hyderabad and Mirpurkhas, each receiving between 100 and 190 mm of rain. Chief meteorologist Mohammad Riaz said the figures were a 51-year record, and the rains would continue for the rest of the week. Pakistan’s meteorological department says average rainfall across Sindh is three times normal, with the worst-affected districts of Badin, Mirpurkhas and Thar seeing eight times the usual levels. This year’s rains, though concentrated in Sindh, have already affected 5.3 million people and 1.2 million homes in the province’s 23 districts, with 1.7 million acres of arable land inundated according to the National Disaster Management Authority’s (NDMA) initial assessment. (Read: Floods worsen, 270 killed, says officials) Over 12,000 heads of cattle have perished while millions have been displaced, added Sindh minister for livestock Abid Hussain Jatoi. “Mirpurkhas, Tharparker, Badin and Khairpur are the worst affected districts for livestock,” he added. UN flash appeal The United Nations (UN) would launch a formal flash appeal for meeting the financial requirements of early relief phase in flood-affected areas of Sindh, possibly before the end of September, sources in the Economic Affairs Division (EAD) told The Express Tribune. The UN has already launched a rapid needs assessment and officials from the organization and its allied agencies have completed visits to the affected districts. “On the basis of rapid needs assessment, the UN will launch a flash appeal to seek global financial assistance for Pakistan,” confirmed the local UN spokesperson Ishrat Rizvi. The rapid assessment report is expected to be completed within one week, she added. Last year, the UN had made a $1.9 billion appeal for early relief and recovery phases. Against the overall appeal, around 70% pledges were materialised by international donors, Rizvi said. The need for the flash appeal was triggered after the government declared that it would not be able to handle the catastrophe within its own limited resources. This is the second flash appeal being launched by the UN, the first one issued after last year’s super floods which killed 2,000 people, left a fifth of the country under water and affected around 21 million people. Local officials, however, say devastation in the province is worse than last year. The UN’s World Food Programme agency is working to provide emergency supplies to half a million people while the United States said it is sending food aid for nearly 350,000 and medical assistance for about 500,000 people. Inadequate response Head of the prime minister’s committee on rain damage Qamar Zaman Kaira expressed his discontent over rescue and relief operations being carried out in rain-affected areas. More than 5.5 million people have been affected in lower Sindh and the majority of the people are still stranded in their areas, he said while addressing a joint press conference at the Chief Minister House on Tuesday. Admitting the inadequacy of the government’s response, Kaira said that “only 80,000 tents have been provided to the rain victims while the rest have been living without any shelter.” “It has disappointed us,” he said, adding that the government has contacted tent manufacturing companies to provide an additional four to five thousand tents. Separately, EAD officials said that the government can provide up to 93,000 tents while the country immediately needs another 100,000. Kaira said that they would hold another meeting on Wednesday to finalise relief and rescue efforts. Senators step up Senate Deputy Chairman Jan Muhammad Jamali constituted two special committees, procurement and distribution headed by Senators Seemen Yusuf Siddiqui and Sardar Ali Khan respectively, to work for flood victims in Sindh. (Read: Mitigating Misery – Senators urge special relief package) Senator Haji Ghulam Ali was deputed to coordinate with the chambers of commerce across the country for fund raising while, the special committees will arrange for 6,000 bags containing food items on an emergency basis. The senators raised an amount of Rs11.4 million on Tuesday while lawmakers also extended donations of Rs25,000 each from their next month salary. Some senators, however, asked for the donation to be reduced to Rs10,000, citing non-affordability. WITH ADDITIONAL INPUT BY HAFEEZ TUNIO IN KARACHI, ZAHID GISHKORI IN ISLAMABAD AND AGENCIES. Published in The Express Tribune, September 14th, 2011. REFERENCE: Sindh rains By Shahbaz Rana / Z Ali Published: September 14, 2011 http://tribune.com.pk/story/252034/sindh-rains-govt-scrambles-as-un-prepares-to-launch-aid-appeal/ 

News Night with Talat - 3 (11/12/11)



URL: http://youtu.be/vdqKPONji0w


HYDERABAD: The government is yet to complete its assessment of losses suffered by the agriculture sector in Sindh due to the monsoon rains but officials estimate devastation of around 140,000 acres in Mirpurkhas district alone. According to the official estimates, crops are sown over 205,000 acres in Mirpurkhas. “Up to 80 percent of the cotton crop standing over 40,200 acres has been washed away by the rains,” District Agriculture Officer, Mirpurkhas, Yar Muhammad Khaskheli told newsmen on Wednesday. Heavy monsoon rains caused flash-floods in Umerkot, Tharparkar, Sanghar, Mirpurkhas, Tando Muhammad Khan and Badin with the provincial government declaring four of them as calamity hit districts. DCO Mirpurkhas Ghulam Hussain Memon told the local media that nearly 22,000 people have been provided shelter in the relief camps. The rains affected 32 union councils with 24 of them officially declared as calamity hit. According to the DCO, around 200,000 people have been affected by the rains. Abdul Majeed Nizamani, president Sindh Abadgar Board believes that cotton crop sowed over about 1.2 million acres in Tando Muhammad Khan, Badin, Tando Allahyar, Mirpurkhas and Sanghar districts has been damaged or destroyed. “The price of per acre yield of cotton crop is at least Rs73,000 according to the estimates of Agriculture Research Department.” Cotton, which need less than half feet of water for cultivation, cannot withstand two to four feet water for several days as the plant wilts for want of oxygen. Besides cotton, other crops like paddy, chillies, sugarcane and vegetables have also suffered badly. “Nearly 90 percent of chilli crop cultivated over 17,500 acres, 25 percent of sugarcane crop sown at around 46,600 acres and 90 percent of 40,800 acres of vegetables have been destroyed,” says Yar Muhammad Khaskheli, the district agriculture officer. Published in The Express Tribune, August 18th, 2011. REFERENCE: Crop damage: Rains wreak havoc in Sindh By Z Ali Published: August 18, 2011 http://tribune.com.pk/story/233705/crop-damage-rains-wreak-havoc-in-sindh/

News Night with Talat - 4 (11/12/11)



URL: http://youtu.be/IWs2x3rG0I4


THE recent floods in Sindh have triggered a debate in the media about the role of the Left Bank Outfall Drain (LBOD) in exacerbating the disaster in the south-eastern districts of the province. Much has been said and written about how the LBOD, meant for the drainage of excessive irrigation water from Nawabshah, Sanghar and Mirpurkhas districts into the Arabian Sea, has turned out to be a recurring cause of flood disaster since the 1999 cyclone in lower Sindh. The debate focusing on the LBOD issue draws attention towards the much larger issue of `drainage crisis` engineered by international aid through man-made structural interventions in irrigation and drainage in the Indus basin — the only river basin of the country. The portion of land drained by a river and its tributaries is the river basin. It encompasses an area of land where surface water from rain and melting snow converges on a single point called the exit of the basin, and eventually flows into an estuary, a lake, an ocean or a sea. The Indus basin is one of the largest basins in Asia. It extends over four countries including China, India, Afghanistan and Pakistan. Around 56 per cent of the Indus basin lies in Pakistan. The British Raj introduced a modern irrigation system with perennial water supplies through mega structural measures like headworks, weirs and barrages on the rivers. Such interventions in the Indus basin commenced in 1859 with the completion of the Upper Bari Doab Canal (MBDC) from the Madhopur Headworks (now in India) on the Ravi. REFERENCE: Drainage crisis in Indus basin By Azhar Lashari | From the Newspaper The writer works for an international anti-poverty organisation. http://www.dawn.com/2011/10/13/drainage-crisis-in-indus-basin.html  Crop Damages as on 14.08.2011 http://www.pdma.pk/dn/CropDamages/tabid/129/Default.aspx 



However, considerable expansion of the irrigation network in the Indus basin took place in the decades following independence. That expansion was possible because of international aid (read loan). With three storage reservoirs, two headworks, 16 barrages, 12 interlink canals, 44 canal systems, more than 64,000km of canals and 90,000 water courses in the Indus basin today, Pakistan has one of the largest contiguous irrigation systems in the world. The huge infrastructure has made it possible to divert 101 million acre feet (MAF) out of the 154 MAF annual water flow in the Indus basin for feeding the canal system, thereby intensifying irrigation in the country. Out of a total of 52.75 million acres of cropped area, the average annual irrigated area constitutes 40 million acres. Of this, 34.5 million acres are irrigated through the canal irrigation system. But from the outset, the intensive irrigation network has unleashed a range of social and environmental problems including marginalisation of the landless and indigenous people, demographic imbalances tilted in favour of powerful political and ethnic groups, the erosion of flora and fauna, and last but not least, land degradation in the form of waterlogging and salinity. However, the only problem that has attracted the attention of policymakers has been waterlogging and salinity. To fix the problem, structural measures like the Salinity Control and Rehabilitation Project (SCARP), Main Nara Valley Drain (MNVD), LBOD, National Drainage Programme (NDP) and the Right Bank Outfall Drain (RBOD) were undertaken. katcha nashaib pucca. The huge irrigation and drainage network developed over one and a half centuries has created an unprecedented drainage crisis in the country. The construction of storage reservoirs, barrages, weirs and other engineering works across and along the Indus rivers has seriously obstructed natural drainage in the Indus basin — both in low-lying ( or ) areas and high lands (). The riverbeds that developed over thousands of years have been squeezed into narrow passages, not allowing peak flood flows to pass smoothly. For instance, the Indus bed previously spanned 14-20km in the plains of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, south-western Punjab and Sindh before the advent of the modern irrigation regime that saw the construction of embankments. It has now been reduced to not more than 2km. pucca In addition, the accumulation of silt in reservoirs as well as in beds has further reduced the carrying capacity of rivers, besides increasing water velocity and intensifying bank erosion. Similarly, the development of canal and drainage infrastructure in lands has obstructed the natural drainage of streams and hill torrents that ultimately are discharged into the river basin. REFERENCE: Drainage crisis in Indus basin By Azhar Lashari | From the Newspaper The writer works for an international anti-poverty organisation. http://www.dawn.com/2011/10/13/drainage-crisis-in-indus-basin.html  Crop Damages as on 14.08.2011 http://www.pdma.pk/dn/CropDamages/tabid/129/Default.aspx

For instance, the development of canals branching out from Chashma, Taunsa, Guddu and Sukkur barrages, and the RBOD have seriously complicated the drainage of hill torrents on the right bank of the Indus in southern Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, south-western Punjab and western Sindh. Last year`s floods and the extraordinary torrential rain in Sindh in 2011 have revealed how the drainage crisis of the Indus basin has turned out to be a permanent flood hazard, exposing the people of the country — particularly those living in Sindh and south-western Punjab — to new risks and vulnerabilities. As mega irrigation and drainage projects involve enormous economic costs and technical expertise, international financial institutions (IFIs) have been at the centre of efforts to promote a techno-centric approach to water development in Pakistan. They have played a role not only in complicating the drainage crisis in the Indus basin but also in incurring a heavy foreign debt. The World Bank (WB) and Asian Development Bank (ADB) have prescribed, supported and funded many mega structures like the Tarbela Dam, Chashma Right Bank Irrigation Project, LBOD, NDP, Chotiari Dam, Taunsa Barrage, the Emergency Rehabilitation and Modernisation Project (TBERMP), etc that are socially unjust, politically exclusionary, economically exploitative and environmentally disastrous. It is high time to find a sustainable solution to the drainage crisis in the Indus basin, besides holding WB and ADB accountable for inflicting death, disease, hunger and livelihood disruptions on hundreds of thousands people affected by last year`s floods and this year`s heavy rains in Sindh. The IFIs must be pushed to compensate the people. REFERENCE: Drainage crisis in Indus basin By Azhar Lashari | From the Newspaper The writer works for an international anti-poverty organisation. http://www.dawn.com/2011/10/13/drainage-crisis-in-indus-basin.html  Crop Damages as on 14.08.2011 http://www.pdma.pk/dn/CropDamages/tabid/129/Default.aspx

Thursday, October 6, 2011

Flood in Sindh & Design of Left Bank Outfall Drain (LBOD).

Muhammad Ismail, 56, is tended by his family in a U.N. camp alongside a road between the cities of Hyderabad and Thatta on Sept. 28. He suffered a stroke due to a brain tumor and has received some medical treatment, but the family does not have enough money to continue treatment. In August 2011, heavy monsoon rains triggered flooding in lower parts of Sindh and northern parts of Punjab provinces. To date, the Pakistani government reports that more than 5.3 million people have been affected -- more than 200 people have lost their lives, over 4.2 million acres of land flooded, and 1.59 million acres of crops destroyed. Photojournalist Sam Phelps documented this nation underwater while on assignment for the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees. REFERENCE: Are You So Mad at Pakistan You Can't Feel Sorry for Them? Tragic photos of a nation underwater. PHOTOGRAPHS BY SAM PHELPS | OCTOBER 4, 2011 http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2011/10/04/are_you_so_mad_at_pakistan_you_cant_feel_sorry_for_them?page=0,0

WITH the recent monsoon experience, the question of whether the Left Bank Outfall Drain (LBOD) is the primary cause of flooding in lower Sindh districts has resurfaced. Originally, the drain was designed to channel excessive irrigation water during floods and the runoff of waterlogged lands in Shaheed Benazirabad (formally Nawabshah), Sanghar and Mirpurkhas districts into the Arabian Sea at Zero Point in Badin district. The project, funded by the Asian Development Bank (ADB) and the World Bank (WB), was additionally meant to carry industrial and municipal effluent from urban centres. However, due to numerous gaps in the design, operational, technical and monitoring dimensions, the drain has in fact been causing heavy damage from time to time. The sufferers include human populations, biodiversity and crops, especially when the lower Sindh area is hit by cyclones and heavy rains. The LBOD has been serving as a ready channel for seawater to flow upward and encroach upon Sindh’s ecologically important and fertile areas. This was observed in the wake of the 1999 cyclone, when encroaching seawater caused severe damage. The cyclone hit the 41-kilometre tidal link canal of the LBOD, which split open in 65 places and caused massive losses in Badin. The scale of the tragedy is underlined by the fact that 355 bodies of children and adults were pulled out of the mud. Faulty design was traced as the major reason behind the tidal link’s weakness. Badin’s coastal community believes that had the LBOD not existed, cyclone-related losses could have been minimised by up to 80 per cent. REFERENCE: Revisiting the LBOD issue By Jamil Junejo - The writer works with the Pakistan Fisherfolk Forum and was associated with the Manila-based NGO on ADB Forum. http://www.dawn.com/2011/10/06/revisiting-the-lbod-issue.html

Short Film on Left Bank Outfall Drain (LBOD) by Participatory Development Initiative (PDI)



Courtesy: Participatory Development Initiative [PDI] http://www.pdi.org.pk/index.php


Q. What are some of the key lessons learned from the LBOD experience? -  A. An important lesson learned from the operating history of LBOD is the degree to which critical aspects of a project’s design, functions, and associated risks must be communicated to all stakeholders at an early stage of project development and implementation, and the extent to which they must “buy into” the project and understand its limitations, risks and implications, as well as enjoy its benefits. . These limitations and risks are not fixed. They stem in part from what each alternative can achieve technically and feasibly and their cost, as well as from the choices made among all the alternatives and the tradeoffs inherent in these choices. The process of considering all these factors must be based on sound and appropriate knowledge base and good engineering, but it must also provide local stakeholders an opportunity to participate fully in influencing the options and making these choices. This is also important because as the experience of LBOD suggests, participation of local stakeholders goes beyond expressing preference for one option over another, to a direct role in the successful operation and maintenance of the scheme itself. Local stakeholders include not only farmer, fisherfolk and other beneficiaries and households in the many settlements and villages in the area, but also local government authorities who must shoulder the burden of flood warning, preparedness and response, the provincial authorities who will provide the financing, and the institutions responsible for O&M of the system. REFERENCE: Sindh Q&A: Agricultural Drainage and LBOD http://www.worldbank.org.pk/WBSITE/EXTERNAL/COUNTRIES/SOUTHASIAEXT/PAKISTANEXTN/0,,contentMDK:21102935~pagePK:141137~piPK:141127~theSitePK:293052,00.html#question11

Similar havoc linked to the LBOD was wreaked in Badin during the floods of 2003. The drain swelled beyond its capacity which resulted in breaches and overflows. After surveying the damage, the Pakistan Fisherfolk Forum reported: “More than 32 people were killed, 50,000 acres of standing crops were damaged, more than 100,000 people were displaced for three months, about 12,000 fishermen lost their single source of livelihood, and more than 10,000 acres of land [were] encroached [upon] by seawater during the rains and floods in 2003.” In the recent floods, the existence of the drain has had a similar impact. Damage was inflicted on communities and arable lands in not just Badin but also Shaheed Benazirabad, Sanghar and Mirpurkhas. The first area, however, bore the brunt of the fury. A report prepared jointly by the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organisation and Pakistan’s Space and Upper Atmosphere Research Commission (Suparco) blames the LBOD for the destruction brought on Tando Mohammad Khan, Badin and Mirpurkhas districts. The gravity of the damage, and its geographical limits, has been wider this time. The LBOD project should never have been pursued in the first place. Neither the design nor the implantation plan was feasible or participatory. Indeed, they lacked both wisdom and farsightedness. While the project proponents and implementers were focusing on the LBOD as a tool in drainage, they failed to consider it as a possible threat. The project was riddled with violations of not just various national and international laws but also the ADB and WB safeguard policies on involuntarily resettlement. The issues of preservation of climate and the protection of lakes were not considered, and the public was kept unaware of the project’s potential impact. Breaches in the LBOD and its tidal link have resulted in the degradation of a large area of land by contaminating the groundwater with salt. This has resulted in depriving a large number of people of potable water. The United Nations General Assembly declared the right to water as a basic right in 2010; the forum has proclaimed the 2005-2015 period as the international decade for action for ‘Water for Life’. The degradation of cultivable land and the resultant contraction of livelihood opportunities have deprived a large number of people of their right to food ensured in Article 25 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Article 19 of the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, ratified by Pakistan in 2008, recognises freedom from hunger as a fundamental right. With regard to biodiversity, the extinction of fish species as a result of the LBOD could be held to violate the UN Convention on Biodiversity, signed and ratified by Pakistan in 1994. Efficient functioning of the LBOD required social and political oversight. These were absent during the project’s design and implementation stages. Despite several initiatives by groups and individuals such as the ‘save the coast’ committee in Badin and an anti-LBOD movement, the project was pushed through. Had these initiatives been taken before or during the project’s implementation, work could have been halted. Interested parties filed a complaint in the World Bank’s Inspection Panel on Sept 9, 2004. After investigation, the panel justified the allegation levelled by the anti-LBOD movement and submitted its finding to the WB’s board of directors in mid-2006. In response, the bank management provided an action plan to the board which was approved on Oct 31, 2006. Unfortunately, the plan failed to correspond with the major recommendations of the anti-LBOD movement. Instead of taking genuine and result-oriented measures, the bank made foul use of the losses. It gave financial assistance in the form of grants to some NGOs through the Pakistan Poverty Alleviation Fund. These funds were meant to implement various activities to compensate those affected by the LBOD. Subsequently, the anti-LBOD movement weakened and ultimately became dysfunctional. In view of the damage wrought during the recent floods, it is time the movement mustered up its strength again. Before renewing the campaign, it should revisit its previous demands in relation to the present context. The priority list must be topped by the demand to decommission the LBOD. First, its low capacity can’t withstand pressure. Secondly, it has been weakened by poor maintenance. If it is not decommissioned, it will continue to bring disaster. REFERENCE: Revisiting the LBOD issue By Jamil Junejo - The writer works with the Pakistan Fisherfolk Forum and was associated with the Manila-based NGO on ADB Forum. http://www.dawn.com/2011/10/06/revisiting-the-lbod-issue.html LBOD: The culprit behind recurring floods in Sindh? By Farooq Tirmizi Published: September 30, 2011 http://tribune.com.pk/story/263570/lbod-the-culprit-behind-recurring-floods-in-sindh/

Experience of Inspection Process in LBOD case - Center for Peace and Civil Society (CPCS) is a non-profit civic initiative that was established in 2001 and was registered in 2005 at Hyderabad, Sindh, Pakistan. It was established by a group of scholars and practitioners from diverse backgrounds ranging from politics to media and academia to writers and intellectuals. CPCS is an independent think-tank that works for strengthening the political and civil society based on principles of democracy, freedom, secularism and social justice. CPCS works with political parties, youth, women, mass media and other non-governmental institutions. CPCS has placed a unique example of creativity, credibility and commitment through civic courage, transparent practices and highest professional standards. www.cpcs.org.pk/docs/presentations/LBOD-by%20Saleh.ppt















Monday, October 3, 2011

Flood in Sindh but World Bank See No Suffering, Hear No Cries, Speak No Truth.

In the case of Left Bank Outfall Drainage Project (LBOD)(Pakistan), the failure of Sindh Irrigation and Drainage Authority to consider concerns raised by local indigenous communities on wrong discharge design of the project resulted in damages of irrigation, groundwater quality and ecosystem. In the case of Chashma Right Bank Irrigation Project (CRBIP) (Pakistan), the consultations were carried out just to fulfil project obligations and did not really mean to take note of what the people had to suggest. Displacement due to flood could have been prevented had there been meaningful peoples’ participation in the project (CRBIP) taking into account local knowledge and expertise. REFERENCE: RUNNING DRY Does the ADB Stand for “Water for All”? Synthesis Report of the Civil Society Organizations to the Implementation Review of the Asian Development Bank Water Policy 18th November 2005 Quezon City, Philippines NGO Forum http://www.forum-adb.org/docs/Running-Dry-ExecutiveSummary.pdf

The rains in southern Pakistan have inflicted unprecedented miseries upon millions of people. Already over 200 people have died, over six million rendered homeless, crops over two million acres destroyed and billions more worth of homes, livestock and infrastructure damaged in several districts of lower Sindh alone. The tragedy is still unfolding and these numbers are going to get worse. Soon water borne diseases will take their own toll as water levels recede. Millions of affectees in these districts – already among the poorest of Pakistanis – would be desperately struggling with new problems of rising poverty and loss of livelihood. So far, no one other than the government agencies has been seen in the field. Our Philanthropic private sector, aid agencies and NGOs absent are visibly absent? There is no doubt that the country has been battered with exceptionally heavy rains again this year. But by all indications, nature’s fury has been compounded by man-made disasters inflicted upon cities as well as the countryside in the shape of faulty designs, shoddy construction and poor monitoring of ‘development’ projects, choked and reverse-flowing municipal drains, broken roads and bridges to the severely flawed project of Left Bank Outfall Drain (LBOD) which has been blocking outflows of flood drainage and allowing inflows of sea water into settled areas during high tides in the Arabian Sea. So much money has been consumed by these ‘development’ projects but when tested, they have only compounded the people’s miseries. The LBOD cost Pakistan over a billion dollars in loan money and was sponsored by a consortium led by the World Bank and assisted by the Asian Development Bank and by some friendly bilateral donor countries to address water logging and salinity problems. Complaints by local communities and official agencies, which had topographical and historical knowledge of water flows, went unheard from the very beginning in 1980s, as the project was designed, executed and monitored between the World Bank and Wapda. The damage inflicted on local communities by the flawed design of this project showed itself during the cyclone of 1999 and floods of 2003. The current havoc caused by the rains has once again reminded us of the recurring problems caused by the malfunctioning LBOD. A World Bank appointed inspection panel had confirmed the validity of the people’s complaints but the rectifications for these admittedly serious flaws have still not been made by the bank management as far as compensation for loss of life, property and livelihood of these communities is concerned. The staff of financial institutions, like the World Bank and Asian Bank, that is directly involved from the project designing to selection of consultants to monitoring, has clear fiduciary duties to ensure that loan funds are used for the benefit of the country and the targeted communities. REFERENCE: An albatross named LBOD Syed Mohibullah Shah Tuesday, September 20, 2011 The writer designed the Board of Investment and the First Women Bank. Email: smshah@alum.mit.edu http://www.thenews.com.pk/TodaysPrintDetail.aspx?ID=68476&Cat=9 

Front Line [Flood Special] with Kamran Shahid - 14th Sep 2011 Part 1

URL: http://youtu.be/vYw7z4bH7p0


In some cases the World Bank has debarred companies and consultants responsible for the flaws and promised aid to the affected communities. One would expect that the World Bank group president, Robert Bruce Zoellick, would ask the bank management to extend similar support to the long suffering affectees of the LBOD project also. The law of fiduciary duties is very clear and puts legal and enforceable obligations upon all such entities – local and foreign – that are entrusted with the agency’s responsibilities towards the owners – stockholders in private companies and citizens where public money is used. In Pakistan, repeated scandals rocking the stock market and disasters in the public sector are largely caused by our neglect of understanding and application of the law of fiduciary duties upon those responsible. The results of non enforcement of frequent violations of the fiduciary duties of care and loyalty have given license to various malpractices and made Pakistan into a country where so much money has been spent over the years – foreign and domestic – with so little to show for it in real benefits to people. While some know-all foreign consultants are rightly criticised for their hubris and insensitivity to knowledge and experience regarding local problems while designing costly projects, equally culpable are local authorities which fail in doing their duty diligently in properly scrutinising and evaluating these ‘big ticket’ projects, but are nevertheless in indecent haste to stamp their approvals of poorly designed and half-baked projects. Joseph Stiglitz, who was the chief economist of the World Bank and later received the Nobel Prize for Economics had intimate first hand knowledge of how such things really happen. Talking of why foreign aid in many cases does not produce the desired results and on the contrary creates resentment, he observed before a Congressional hearing; “It’s important that the beneficiaries of the aid are not just western consulting firms looking for fat contracts, but also the people and the communities that we want to help.” REFERENCE: An albatross named LBOD Syed Mohibullah Shah Tuesday, September 20, 2011 The writer designed the Board of Investment and the First Women Bank. Email: smshah@alum.mit.edu http://www.thenews.com.pk/TodaysPrintDetail.aspx?ID=68476&Cat=9 

Front Line [Flood Special] with Kamran Shahid - 14th Sep 2011 Part 2

URL: http://youtu.be/CibCslfQ-Mk


He went on to add, “Recipient officials (of developing countries) who welcomed the consultants at first, but after hundreds of fact-finding meetings with an endless array of consultants from donor organisations and the international financial institutions, many officials were disillusioned and frustrated.” This story is still being repeated in Pakistan as some important projects are getting underway under the Kerry-Lugar-Berman aid package. While the LBOD problems have concrete visibility in terms of concentrated damage to human life, crops and properties, there are several other ‘big ticket’ projects whose damage, though dispersed and less visible in concrete terms, has been no less to the goals of national development. Often these are shoved under the carpet to cover our own inadequacies and failures to fulfil fiduciary duties as far as foreign entities are concerned. While there are several other similar stories, I will relate one regarding a ‘big ticket’ project launched by the Social Action Programme (SAP) during the 1990s with World Bank’s and the Pakistan government’s funds. This was one of those projects where even the donor community disputed our unrealistic claims and questioned the skewed incentives, unsustainability and ad hoc deviations of multimillion dollars by SAP from its original intent and objectives. A real life glimpse into the workings in Pakistan may suffice to elaborate this. The day this project was approved by the government of Pakistan, this writer was informed the same evening by some very surprised staff members of the Islamabad office of the World Bank of how things happened on that fateful day. The bank staff and their consultants had spent several days preparing for all kinds of likely questions and critiques from the Pakistani side in what was expected to be at least a day-long marathon session, as the project details would come up for approval. They could not believe their eyes and ears when the meeting, in which the approvals for this project were given and multimillion dollar loan liabilities accepted by Pakistani, did not even last thirty minutes! It is no wonder, therefore, to face the bitter fact that while Pakistan has been one of the largest recipients of foreign aid and its debt mountain has become unsustainable, there is so little to show on ground for so much money spent over the years. Some knowledgeable foreign observers have dubbed the story of ‘development’ in Pakistan as both ‘hilarious and heartbreaking’. Heartbreaking indeed! REFERENCE: An albatross named LBOD Syed Mohibullah Shah Tuesday, September 20, 2011 The writer designed the Board of Investment and the First Women Bank. Email: smshah@alum.mit.edu http://www.thenews.com.pk/TodaysPrintDetail.aspx?ID=68476&Cat=9 

Front Line [Flood Special] with Kamran Shahid - 14th Sep 2011 Part 3

URL: http://youtu.be/1_6QddnKdK4


The recent floods caused by heavy monsoon rains have inflicted a loss of Rs 216.6 billion on the country while crops on an estimated 2.1 million acres of land have been damaged including 74 percent of cotton crop, 26 percent rice and 34 percent sugarcane. According to the documents available with Business Recorder, 74 percent loss to the cotton crop means Rs 121 billion in monetary term; loss to rice crop is Rs 15 billion and Rs 20 billion to sugarcane. Whereas loss to chillies is estimated at Rs 41 billion, tomatoes Rs 1.1 billion, onion Rs 11 billion and Rs 976 million loss to musk melon. The government has to bear Rs 2.7 billion loss in terms of Kharif vegetables and Rs 2.4 billion due to damages to banana orchards. "If the crop area remains under the flood water for the next 2-3 days, the land would not remain cultivable for the next year due to salinity and water-logging," sources said. It may be mentioned here that the 2010 floods had caused a total loss of Rs 2 million to cotton bales. The floods damaged standing sugarcane crop on 0.2 million hectares. About 0.7 million tons wheat stock was damaged. Paddy's damage was 1.5 million tons, mostly of Irri-6 in Sindh. Sources said: "The loss to farm output during 2010 floods was less than that of current year's. Last year, the crops in just 8 districts of Sindh were affected while in 2011, the Kharif crops in 21 to 22 districts of lower Sindh have been damaged." Rains have hit 21 districts of Sindh, but nine of them have been badly affected including Badin, Mirpurkhas, Tharparkar, Tando Muhammad Khan, Tando Allahyar, Matiari, Umerkot, Sanghar and Benazirabad. The Sindh province contributes significantly towards overall national agriculture production in major crops: 32 percent in rice, 24 percent in cotton, 12 percent in sugarcane, 21 percent in wheat. Sources said that the total crop area damaged in Mirpurkhas is estimated at 1.2 lakh acres, in Tharparkur 3,946 acres, in Umerkot 67,749 acres, in T A Yar 65,320 acres, in T M Khan 70,111 acres, in Badin 3.1 lakh acres, in Thatta 1.3 lakh acres and in Sanghar 3.3 lakh acres. In Hyderabad district, the total crop area damaged is estimated at 21,719 acres, in Matiari, 68,031 acres, Shaheed Benazirabad 1.5 lakh acres, N S Feroze 67,536 acres, Khairpur 1.7 lakh acres, Sukkur 25,404 acres, and in Ghotki 68,424 acres. REFERENCE: Pakistan. Floods cause Rs 216.6 billion loss http://www.blackseagrain.net/photo/pakistan.-floods-cause-rs-216.6-billion-loss 

Front Line [Flood Special] with Kamran Shahid - 14th Sep 2011 Part 4

URL: http://youtu.be/87-E-KsaF0U

HYDERABAD: Sanghar remains underwater with no immediate signs of a drop in the water level. The government’s efforts to drain the district, meanwhile, are being met with suspicion by the business community. Eid, on August 30, brought with it a second spell of monsoon rains that left the cotton-rich district under several feet of water. The authorities are now faced with the knotty situation of draining out that water. Their solution – an improvised drain dug along the city’s trade centre on MA Jinnah Road. The drain — about 500 metres long, six foot deep and four foot wide — is meant to draw water from the district and direct it towards a natural route to the Left Bank Outfall Drain (LBOD), explained the town municipal administrator, Maluk Khaskheli. “It will pump (water) off towards the Sanghar-Khairpur square. From that point, the water will flow over the agricultural fields towards the LBOD.” Khaskheli explains that a pump, 12 inches in diameter has been installed to suck out water from MA Jinnah Road while other areas still await their pumps. Issues arise, however, when you take into account the fact that MA Jinnah Road has a number of shops located all along it. Liaquat Market, Saeed Market, Shahi Bazaar, Nawabshah Road, Thana Road are markets that sell everything from agricultural inputs and goods to grocery, jewellery, cosmetics and medical stores. REFERENCE: Sanghar desperately tries to drain MA Jinnah Road - only to have more water flow in By Z Ali Published: October 3, 2011 http://tribune.com.pk/story/265441/sanghar-desperately-tries-to-drain-ma-jinnah-road-only-to-have-more-water-flow-in/ 


Super Flood in Sanghar By ApnaSanghar.com

URL: http://youtu.be/K3KMeIOnh7U


Sanghar Civil Hospital By ApnaSanghar.com

URL: http://youtu.be/gO2sFK6geEM


Mirpurkhas Complete report after stopping rain in Sindh

URL: http://youtu.be/7KNnOkk4F0Y

The business community considers the plan ineffective. “They dug the ditch on Saturday and, by that evening, the process of sucking water out began. Yet, almost two days into it, we still find our legs in as much water as they were then,” bemoans Malik Sher Muhammad, senior vice president of the Sanghar Chamber of Commerce. He highlighted a number of reasons for the plan’s failure. “While they try to drain out water from MA Jinnah Road, the water from the surrounding areas pours in onto the road. Besides, the LBOD is flowing to its full capacity and may not even take more water.” For Muhammad, any efforts towards drainage should include pumping water from all connected areas simultaneously. “Our delegation called on the DCO a day ago and we asked him to throw water into the Bhan Distributary which is empty. But our advice has not been followed,” he said, taking a jab at the lack of official coordination between the district administration and business community. The chamber’s Haji Yameen Qureshi, who trades crops and runs a shop on the road, accuses the municipal administration of procrastination. “It has been over two weeks since it last rained. The work which should have taken place then still lacks a sense of direction.” Qureshi, like Muhammad, also objects to the diversion of water towards the LBOD but suggests that it should be towards Ghaat Parah, which, according to him, is a natural drain. “They need to understand the city’s geography first before making a move.” Two years ago, the former Sanghar nazim laid a new sewerage system in the area. However, the lines have become choked with sludge. Apart from traders, the agriculturalists, whose crops lie ruined under several feet of water, wonder when they will be able to plough their lands again. “The coming days (look bleak for the growers) if urban areas on higher grounds find it difficult to create an outlet for water,” remarked Hassan Askari, the Sindh Small Growers Association general secretary. Sanghar, the country’s top cotton producer, expected to harvest four million bales this year from over 360,000 acres sown. But floods in the irrigation channels have drowned that prospect along with the city itself. Askari said that he heard an irrigation official say that the quantity of floodwater in Sanghar is equal to the water table in the Mangla Dam. “Until the districts above Sanghar are emptied of water, and drains in Badin carry that water to the sea, Sanghar will remain underwater.” Published in The Express Tribune, October 3rd, 2011. REFERENCE: Sanghar desperately tries to drain MA Jinnah Road - only to have more water flow in By Z Ali Published: October 3, 2011 http://tribune.com.pk/story/265441/sanghar-desperately-tries-to-drain-ma-jinnah-road-only-to-have-more-water-flow-in/ 

2609 - News Night with Talat - Ep 232 - Part 02.MOV

URL: http://youtu.be/-rkOM35A5Uc


KARACHI, Sept 9: Unprecedented torrential monsoon rains lashing Sindh and causing flash flooding in 16 districts of the province have a direct linkage with global climate change, says a climate expert.Responding to Dawn queries, Federal Advisor on Climate Affairs Dr Qamar-uz-Zaman Chaudhry said that the volume of total water fallen over Sindh during the four weeks period is estimated to be over 37 million acres feet.The pattern of extreme weather events in Pakistan in the recent past has shown a clear indication of increased frequency and intensity of such events in Pakistan, in line with international climate change projections, he stated. Dr Qamar, who is associated with the formulation of the country’s first draft National Climate Change Policy, explained that rains in Sindh during the four-week period are the highest-ever recorded monsoon rains. Before the start of these rains in the second week of August 2011, Sindh was under severe drought conditions  and did not receive any rainfall in the previous 12 months, he explained. A previous severe rainfall, which led to flooding in the province, had occurred in July 2003. But this time devastative rains of over 1,150mm in Mithi; Mirpurkhas (676mm); Diplo (779mm); Chhachhro (735mm); Nagar Parkar (792mm); Nawabshah (547mm); Badin (512mm); Chhor (456mm); Padidan (318mm); Hyderabad (249mm), etc., have created unparallel flooding in Sindh.The area might not have seen rains of such a magnitude in recent years.The rainfall, he said, was predicted well in advance by the meteorological offices, and the disaster management agencies were also well-prepared, but owing to the scale of this natural calamity (combined with the topography of the area having very poor natural drainage), most water stagnated and breaches in Left-Bank Outfall Drain and irrigation channels further complicated the scale of flooding. He said that weathermen had been warning that climate change would cause a considerable increase in frequency and intensity of extreme weather events, coupled with erratic monsoon rains, causing floods and droughts. Moreover, a further increase in temperature may result in enhanced heat and water stress conditions, particularly in arid and semi-arid regions. Dr Qamar said it is very difficult to link any single weather event to a climate change, if we look at the frequency and trend of extreme weather events impacting Pakistan, it would be easy to find its linkage with climate change. He said that the pattern of extreme weather events in Pakistan in the recent past is showing a clear indication of increased frequency and intensity of such events in Pakistan which are in line with international climate change projections. The climate change has become a reality for Pakistan, he stressed. The climate expert said clearly Pakistan is heading for an increased frequency and intensity of extreme weather events which included frequent floods and droughts, and the need of the hour is to plan for the future changes. He said that the government had already taken first step in that direction as draft national climate change policy was being formulated. Expert links Sindh rains with climate change By Our Staff Reporter | From the Newspaper September 10, 2011 (4 weeks ago) http://www.dawn.com/2011/09/10/expert-links-sindh-rains-with-climate-change.html 

2609 - News Night with Talat - Ep 232 - Part 03.MOV

URL: http://youtu.be/DZciMfjyiLw


ISLAMABAD, Sept 19: Like last year, nature has come to the rescue of Manchhar Lake this year as heavy monsoon rains over Sindh have washed away contamination and restored for the time being the major source of fresh water supply to the lake. “The calamity of rains has saved Manchhar Lake once again,” Additional Attorney General K.K. Agha told a Supreme Court bench comprising Chief Justice Iftikhar Mohammad Chaudhry, Justice Tariq Pervez and Justice Ghulam Rabbani. The bench had taken up complaints regarding rising pollution due to disposal of effluent from MNV (Main Nara Valley) drain now converted into RBOD-I (Right Bank Outfall Drain) that deprived thousands of fishermen of their source of livelihood. Environmentalists believe that rising pollution is leading Manchhar Lake, one of Asia`s largest freshwater lakes, towards a painful death. Some reports suggest the oldest inhabitants of Sindh called Mohanas usually live on boats and rely on fishing, bird hunting, net making, boat making and farming but the alarming level of toxic particles in the lake has forced them to abandon their profession. Sindh Chief Secretary Raja Mohammad Abbas suggested in a comprehensive report that catchments areas of the lake, like Lukhy Range and Kaccho area spread over Sindh and Balochistan, experienced adequate rainfall during the current monsoon season. It has restored the major source of fresh water supply to the lake and filled it up to 116.5 feet with fresh rainwater, its maximum level being 117 feet. “The nature has resolved the issue of contamination of water of the lake for a considerable span of time probably for at least a year,” the report claimed.The attorney general assured the court that he would request the federal government to release the first tranche of Rs1.3 billion out of the Rs5 billion allocated for completion and commissioning of RBOD-II. Since RBOD-I is also in the close proximity of Haleji Lake, it poses a direct threat to the wetland, once called a birdwatchers` paradise. The lake is already under severe stress because of inadequate water. Earlier, the federal government had accepted Sindh government`s request for Rs5 billion to develop RBOD-II and had suggested re-appropriation from other ongoing projects. In response, the Sindh government referred the matter back to it for reconsideration stating that re-appropriation would mean putting constraints on other projects which were equally important. Alternatively it put a request of release of Rs1.3 billion as first quarter. Engineering experts believe that the extension of RBOD-II to the sea from Sehwan is the only viable solution for the disposal of effluent from RBOD-I. The project was conceived in late 1990s at a cost of Rs29 billion. Sixty per cent of the work has been completed but subsequent work was suspended when fund releases were curtailed to Rs1.5 billion.Referring to the treatment of RBOD effluent, the Sindh chief secretary`s report said that Wapda had proposed installation of five treatment plants on the MNVD before it enters Manchhar Lake. As a first step a pilot treatment plant has been launched for which a feasibility report costing Rs3.3 billion has been cleared by the Central Development Working Party of the Planning Commission and now awaits approval of the Executive Committee of the National Economic Council. In addition, 12 desalination plants will be installed in the Manchhar Lake/RBOD area. Six of them will be installed and maintained by Wapda from its own resources and the rest by the Sindh government. Three desalination plants have been installed and are under operation and about 3,000 gallons of potable water is being distributed among fishermen, though the supply was disturbed because of a fault in the system during the current rainy season. Rains a boon for Manchhar Lake, apex court told By Nasir Iqbal | From the Newspaper September 20, 2011 (2 weeks ago) http://www.dawn.com/2011/09/20/rains-a-boon-for-manchhar-lake-apex-court-told.html 

2609 - News Night with Talat - Ep 232 - Part 04.MOV

URL: http://youtu.be/12eZYRPyAyA


The recent monsoon rains (August to September 2011) have brought great disasters in various districts of Sindh. Record torrential rains in Mirpurkhas, Umerkot, Sanghar, Tharparkar, Thatta, Badin, Tando Muhammad Khan and other districts and towns of Sindh have wreaked havoc leaving more than 200 people including women and children dead and more than 400 people injured, according to reports in media and consolidated figures reported by provincial authorities. First rain spell, started on August 8, 2011, hit hard Mirpurkhas, Badin, Tando Mohammad Khan and parts of Tharparkar like Mithi, Jati in Thatta, Kunri and other areas in Umerkot and Tando Allahyar districts. Second rain spell started on August 30, 2011, which hit hard Khairpur, Naushehro Feroz, Nawabshah, Dadu, Jamshoro, Sanghar, Badin, Mirpurkhas, Umerkot districts.The Federal Advisor on Climate Affairs Dr Qamar-uz-Zaman Chaudhry said that the volume of total water fallen over Sindh during the four weeks period is estimated to be over 37 million acres feet, whereas this devastative rains over 1,150mm in Mithi; Mirpurkhas (676mm); Diplo (779mm); Chhachhro (735mm); Nagar Parkar (792mm); Nawabshah (547mm); Badin (512mm); Chhor (456mm); Padidan (318mm); Hyderabad (249mm), etc., have created unparallel flooding in Sindh.As for Sanghar district, according to Met officials, the 405 mm rainfall was recorded in Shahdadpur followed by 402 mm in Sanghar, 297mm in Sinjhoro and 139 mm in Tando Adam (the talukas of Sanghar District). The government figures showed the 80 percent loss to standing crops, like cotton, paddy, sugarcane, chili and vegetables. It is feared that the displaced people may face food shortage, as they have almost lost the sources of livelihoods and food. Sanghar District was completely submerged in rain and flood water. An estimated 200,000 people have been displaced, some 3500 households were moved from their damaged/inundated houses/villages to nearby roadsides. Some of the families have either migrated to Thar or shifted to the desert areas near Chotyari Reservoir. The affected areas have become mosquito prone which has resulted in spreading malaria cases at alarming level. Besides, very frequent cases of gastro and diarrhea are also being reported. The local hospitals are full of such patients, majority of them are children. Sanghar district administration also called the armed forces to rescue thousands of stranded families in different villages.Sanghar’s connection with Karachi Hyderabad, Hala, Mirpurkhas, Nawabshah and Khipro has been cut off. District Sanghar is basically agro-based producing cotton, wheat and sugarcane. The recent rains have damaged almost 80-90% of the standing crop especially cotton crop as it was mature and was at picking stage. The banana, mango and sugarcane fields are also under deep water. Vegetables i.e. onion, tomato and chilies have been damaged by 80% and their prices have more than doubled. During surveying the affected areas of Sanghar District Qaim Ali Shah, Chief Minister, Sindh, told the reporters, “We have some six million affected people in the province, and it will take time for their rehabilitation.” He declared the Sanghar district calamity hit area and announced Rs 20 million as financial assistance for the rain victims of the district. Taluka Nazim Shahdadpur Faqir Hussain Bux Khaskheli, while addressing a press conference about rain-related damages at TMA Office on September 13, said that out of 13 UCs of taluka 5 were destroyed while remaining UCs also suffered major losses. “Hundred of houses have collapsed while standing crops of worth billions of rupees are inundated,” he added. He was of view Shahdadpur, which was considered as cotton strip, had now become a rain belt. At least 2000 villages have been flooded due to monsoon showers and resultant breaches in canals and saline nullahs, displacing more than 0.2 million people in Shahdadpur sub-division. Hundreds of displaced families have taken refuge in buildings of schools and other govt. buildings while those not so lucky were waiting under open sky for some rescue and relief assistance. The farmers of Sindh who have suffered a colossal loss to their crops in flash floods – estimated to be over 1.6 million acres – have given the government time until October 10 to repair the shattered irrigation system for their Rabi (winter) sowing.The growers fear that after their Kharif (summer) crops were destroyed in the rain, they will also be unable to sow their Rabi crops which would lead to a great deficit in food.“The government should help the affected farmers to cultivate four million acres of wheat crop, 1 million acres of sunflower and different varieties of pulses on 300,000 acres,” they demanded in a meeting of Sindh Abadgar Board. They came forward with detailed recommendations to rebuild irrigation and a list of demands.They asked that the whole province be declared calamity hit, loans be waived off, generous assistance be offered to the affected people, complete government support for the Rabi sowing and the distribution of fertilizers and seeds free or at subsidized prices.Now the soils of Pakistan especially those areas which have received heavy rain and having poor or no drainage system have become victim of water-logging and salinity. Pakistan has already an area of 6.8 million hectares salt affected which directly affects living standard of people. Annual economic loss due to salinity and water-logging problems has been estimated at more than Rs. 20 billion. In this context, Government of Pakistan has spent billions of rupees on hydro-engineering approach (Salinity Control and Reclamation Projects, and National Drainage Programme for combating salinity and water-logging but the results were not encouraging and sustainable primarily because of want of recurrent maintenance and huge O&M costs.Pakistani scientists have done pioneering research to develop alternative approaches to live with salinity for economically utilizing salt-affected lands which led to the development of the concept of Bio-Saline Agriculture. Their research aims at better use of salt affected lands and brackish irrigation water on a sustained basis through integrated use of genetic resources (plants, animals, fish and insects) and improved agricultural practices.Bio-Saline Agriculture Technology’ is an interim, alternative cost-effective solution to salt affected soils and may be profitably applied for economic utilization of our saline environments, till an engineering solution of the problem becomes achievable. However, the benefits of this successful research have not been transferred to the farmers. There is an immense need for its adoption on a national scale by the farmers of the affected lands. Adaptive research has never gained legitimacy because of a top down approach. Its affects on ground in terms of adoption have always been marginal and that too with the big farmers have always remained outside its purview. This requires investments in adaptive research, extension, social mobilization and capacity building and to tackle the problem in a holistic manner in which poverty reduction becomes the centrepiece.Under the current situation of flood and devastative rains, the adaptation of Bio-saline Agriculture Programme becomes more important and is only the economic, cost effective and safe solution which can address the farmer’s affected land. Government of Pakistan should start it with organizing the farmers in the target area and working holistically will try to demonstrate that how to utilize saline lands and generate economic returns and reduce poverty by providing alternate options in Bio-saline agriculture technology. This programme will also try to address the immediate and acute needs of the farmers that can help mitigate salinity/water logging and reduce their poverty through demonstration of benefits of bio-saline technologies. REFERENCE: Solution of flood affected lands Posted on September 20, 2011 Mohammad Ali Khaskheli http://www.thefrontierpost.com/?p=57858 

2609 - News Night with Talat - Ep 232 - Part 05.MOV

URL: http://youtu.be/so7S19XUJU8

The World Bank in Pakistan: See no suffering, hear no cries, speak no truth Mustafa Talpur with A. Ercelan and M. Nauman Pakistan Institute of Labor Education & Research (PILER) http://www.realityofaid.org/userfiles/roareports/roareport_32315c5153.pdf